Politics

Election Petition: Supreme Court dismisses Mahama’s insistence to cross-examine EC Chair

Apexnewsgh

The Supreme Court today, Thursday, February 11 has ruled that Mrs Jean A. Mensa, the Chairperson of the Electoral Commission will not be cross-examined by the Petitioner’s lawyer in the Election 2020 Petition Trial.

The Apex Court ruled same for President Akufo Addo, who also decided not to call a witness in the trial after the Petitioner had closed his case.

“We are reminded to state that our jurisdiction invoked in this election petition is limited jurisdiction clearly circumscribed by law. We do not intend to extend our mandate beyond what the law requires of us in such petitions brought under article 67 clause 1. Simply put, We are not convinced and will not yield to the invitation being extended to us by the counsel for the petitioner to order the respondents to enter the witness box in order to be cross-examined.

“Accordingly, we hereby overrule the objection raised by the counsel for the petitioner against the decision of the respondents declining to adduce testimonies in this petition”, the Chief Justice Justice Anin Yeboah ruled.

However, Lawyer for John Mahama, Tsatsu Tsikata is seeking to file a motion to subpoena the EC chair Jean Mensa to testify.

Lawyers for the EC and President Akufo-Addo had indicated that they were not calling any witnesses in the trial after the Petitioner had called three witnesses and closed his case, though they had filed witness statements.

Mr Justine Amenuvor, lead Counsel for the EC cited Order 36 Rule 43 and Constitutional Instrument (CI) 87 rule 3 (e) 5, Section 62 subsection (2) of the Evidence Act to support his position.

Mr Amenuvor said the EC would not require further evidence to determine the matter before the Court after the Petitioner had closed his case.

He argued that it was the Petitioner who brought them to court, led evidence, and closed his case after calling three witnesses.

“We don’t think we have anything to say. If he has a good case, he should go ahead and be happy dancing. We prayed the Court to uphold our application.”

Mr Akoto Ampaw, lead Counsel for President Akufo-Addo, also associated himself with submissions made by the EC’s lawyer, arguing that the Petitioner’s Counsel’s arguments were “misconceived” and same did address the thrust of their position.

Mr Ampaw was of the opinion that the stands of President Akufo-Addo worked in favour of the Petitioner.

He said under the English Law, a party could raise or notify the court that “it does not intend to adduce evidence in a trial” and same should be done timeously.

Mr Ampaw said, “We are of the view that in the light of CI 37, we are entitled not to adduce evidence. The Petitioner could tender our witness statement as hearsay evidence.”

Mr Tsatsu Tsikata, lead Counsel for the Petitioner, Mr John Dramani Mahama, objected to the EC’s alleged “evasion of cross examination”, adding that Mrs Mensa who represented the EC, had made it known to the Court that she would be mounting the witness box to be cross examined.

Mr Tsikata said that the EC Chairperson explicitly stated that in her affidavit in opposition to the Petitioner’s stay of proceedings and the Petitioner’s application for interrogatories.

Based on that, Mr Tsikata urged the Court to compel the EC Boss to mount the witness box to be cross examined.

He held that the EC Boss, known as the Returning Officer of the 2020 Presidential Election, had a constitutional obligations to perform by declaring the election results.

Mr Tsikata added that, “The EC Boss made representations to the Court and she cannot resign from those representations.”

The Counsel for the Petitioner argued that the EC Boss had carried out a particular responsibility of conducting election 2020 and she ought to render an account for that.

“Her account is to declare who won the mandate of the people and same is captured in issue two of the issues set out by the court to be determined.”

Mr Tsikata stated that the EC’s withdrawal was an “affront to justice” and same was not in accordance with the rules of the Court.

ModernGhana

Please contact Apexnewsgh.com on email apexnewsgh@gmail.com for your credible news publications. Contact: 0555568093

Ngamegbulam C. S

Leave a Reply

does maxsize male enhancement work does natural male enhancement really work does pro plus male enhancement work does quick flow male enhancement work does rite aid sell male enhancement does rite aid sell male enhancement pills does vitamin e help male enhancement does walgreens have male enhancement does walgreens sell male enhancement products does walmart sell male enhancement products dominant male enhancement pills dominant male male enhancement dominant male male enhancement pills dominx male enhancement dominx male enhancement support don juan male enhancement pill don juan male enhancement reviews double x male enhancement double x male enhancement pills dr boss male enhancement dr d male enhancement dr oz best male enhancement dr oz endorsed male enhancement dr oz male enhancement pills and daily vitamins dr oz male enhancement pills reviews dr oz male enhancement recommendations dr oz male enhancement via lax dr oz natural male enhancement dr oz recommended male enhancement pills dr oz show on male enhancement dr phil and steve harvey male enhancement dr sebi male enhancement pills dr tobias male enhancement dr zimmerman male enhancement drachen male enhancement drops drachen male enhancement for sale drachen male enhancement official website drachen male enhancement review drachen male enhancement spray reviews dragon power male enhancement pills dragon strong male tonic enhancer dragon x male enhancement pills dragonflies male enhancement pills dragonfly male enhancement duraflex male enhancement duraflex male enhancement pills duro male enhancement duro xl male enhancement duromax male enhancement duromax testosterone male enhancement reviews dxl male enhancement dynamite super male enhancement reviews dynarex male enhancement e 3 male enhancement e 3 male enhancement pills edge male enhancement effective male enhancement pills effective male enhancement products el toro cbd gummies male enhancement el toro male enhancement cbd gummies el toro male enhancement gummies elite 909 male enhancement elite extra male enhancement elite extreme male enhancements elite male enhancement free trial elite male enhancement review elite male enhancement testosterone booster elite xl male enhancement eliteextreme male enhancement elongate male enhancement elongate male enhancement pills encore male enhancement pills encore natural male enhancement endovex male enhancement endovex male enhancement formula endowmax male enhancement endura natural male enhancement reviews endura naturals male enhancement reddit endura naturals male enhancement scam endura naturals male enhancement video endurance natural male enhancement enduros male enhancement pills enduros male enhancement reviews enduros male enhancement supplement engage x male enhancement enhance male enhancing formula enhance male libido naturally enhance male libido supplements enhance male testosterone naturally enhance xl male enhancement reviews enlarge maxx male enhancement entramax male enhancement enzyte male enhancement commercial enzyte male enhancement pills reviews enzyte natural male enhancement review epic male enhancement pills epic male enhancement side effects erec prime male enhancement erectafil male enhancement gummies erectin male enhancement reviews erex male enhancement reviews erexor male enhancement erorectin male enhancement eroxin male enhancement eruption male enhancement pill reviews erx pro male enhancement erx pro male enhancement pills euphoric male enhancement pill evaxatropin male enhancement reviews ever erect male enhancement everlast male enhancement everyday male enhancement evil root male enhancement evil root male enhancement pills evoxa male enhancement ex100 male enhancement excite male enhancement existence male enhancement existenz male enhancement expandom male enhancement pills explosion male enhancement pill extacy male enhancement pill reviews extacy male enhancement reviews extamax male enhancement exten zone male enhancement extend flow male enhancement reviews extend male enhancement formula extend plus male enhancement extended male enhancement extension plus male enhancement extensions iv male enhancement